Retaining soft skills and hard skills after training: what works for each
Retaining soft skills and hard skills after training: what works for each
Short answer: you maintain hard skills, such as an emergency procedure or traffic rules, by actively recalling them on a regular basis. You maintain soft skills, such as giving feedback or handling a difficult conversation, by applying them in real work and then looking back on what happened. Treat both the same way and you miss half of it. A quiz keeps a procedure sharp, but it does not make anyone a better conversation partner.
Why the distinction matters
Every trainer knows the pattern: the training went well, the evaluations were positive, and three months later there is little to show for it. That is not always down to the training. More often it is about what happens after the training, or what does not.
Research on training transfer makes a useful distinction between closed skills and open skills. A closed skill is performed the same way every time, such as CPR or an evacuation procedure. An open skill has many variations and calls for judgement, such as leadership or a customer conversation. A review of 89 studies (Blume et al., 2010) found that factors such as motivation and support from the work environment are more strongly related to transfer for open skills than for closed skills.
In other words: for soft skills, far more depends on the workplace itself. That is where follow-up needs to focus.
The difference at a glance
| Hard skills | Soft skills | |
|---|---|---|
| Examples | Emergency response and first aid procedures, CPR, safety rules, plant knowledge, traffic rules, product knowledge | Giving feedback, handling a difficult conversation, leadership, customer conversations, collaboration |
| Is there a right answer? | Yes, usually exactly one | Rarely, it depends on the situation |
| What fades | Facts, sequences, actions | The intention to do things differently |
| What works afterwards | Active recall, spaced repetition, short scenarios | Applying it at work, reflection, if-then plans, practising with a colleague |
| What you can measure | Whether someone still knows the answer | What someone says they do, the behaviour itself shows in practice |
Hard skills: recall, at the right moment
With hard skills, it is mainly the knowledge itself that fades. For CPR this is well researched: a systematic review of 34 studies found that skills declined within three months and then stayed roughly level up to six months. Someone who takes a refresher once a year is below their course-day level for much of that year.
Two principles from learning science help most here:
- Retrieval practice. Pulling an answer from memory strengthens retention more than rereading the material (Roediger & Karpicke, 2006). See also retrieval practice.
- Spacing. The same practice time spread over several moments works better than doing it all at once (Cepeda et al., 2006). See also spaced learning.
In practice that means short questions and scenarios spread over weeks, focused on what actually goes wrong. Not 'what is the definition of an emergency responder', but 'you see smoke coming from a fuse box, what do you do first?'
Soft skills: apply, then look back
With soft skills, the problem is rarely that people forget the theory. The problem is that the intention gets lost in a busy week. After a feedback training everyone knows feedback should be specific. The question is whether they do it in Monday's meeting.
What helps:
- A concrete assignment for real work. 'This week, give feedback once using the model from the training.' Small and achievable.
- If-then plans. A plan in the form 'if situation X happens, then I will do Y' makes it more likely that someone acts on an intention. A meta-analysis of 94 studies found a medium-to-large effect on goal attainment (Gollwitzer & Sheeran, 2006).
- Looking back. After the assignment, a short reflection: what went well, what was hard, what will you do differently next time. That is where the learning happens.
- A colleague involved. Practising together, or giving each other brief feedback after a meeting. Support from the environment is one of the strongest factors for open skills.
A quiz on the feedback model can be a useful first step, but here it is never enough.
Example: six weeks after a feedback training
This is what follow-up can look like, with one activation of 5 to 10 minutes per week:
| Week | Activation | What the trainer sees |
|---|---|---|
| 1 | Short recap of the model, plus an if-then plan: 'If I notice something in a meeting that could be better, then...' | Each participant's plan |
| 2 | Assignment: give feedback once this week using the model | Whether the assignment was completed |
| 3 | Reflection: how did it go, what was difficult? | The answers, readable per group |
| 4 | Scenario with an open answer: how do you respond to someone who becomes defensive? | The answer and the feedback on it |
| 5 | Assignment with a colleague: ask for feedback yourself after a meeting | Whether the assignment was completed |
| 6 | Looking back: what do you do differently than six weeks ago? | The answers, as input for the follow-up session |
Example: six weeks after an emergency response training
Same structure, different content. Read more in keeping safety and first-response knowledge sharp.
| Week | Activation |
|---|---|
| 1 | First actions in case of fire, in the right order |
| 2 | Scenario: evacuation while the lift is out of order |
| 3 | Week 1 again, in a different format |
| 4 | When and how do you use the AED? |
| 5 | Your role in the emergency team: who calls, who receives the emergency services? |
| 6 | Short knowledge check across all topics |
The difference is easy to see. Emergency response is about recurring questions with a right answer. Giving feedback is about assignments in real work and looking back.
Honestly: what an app cannot do
You do not change behaviour with an app alone. A platform can make sure things do not go quiet after the training, that assignments arrive at the right moment, and that the trainer sees what participants answer and reflect on.
What an app cannot see is whether someone actually responded differently in Tuesday's meeting. You see that in practice, through the manager, or in the follow-up session. See also from knowledge to behaviour. If you are serious about retaining soft skills, combine three things:
- Short activations between sessions, so the topic stays alive.
- Assignments and reflections about people's own work.
- A moment where someone else sees the behaviour: a manager, a colleague or the trainer.
What this means for your training
Make three choices for each training:
- What do participants need to be able to recall? That calls for short questions and repetition.
- What do participants need to do differently? That calls for assignments, if-then plans and reflection.
- Who sees whether it works? Agree on that with the client beforehand.
Most trainings are a mix. An emergency response training also has a social side, such as staying calm and taking charge. A leadership training also includes knowledge people need to recall. If you are a training provider, this is exactly where you can stand out.
Frequently asked questions
Can you measure soft skills? Not directly with a test. You can measure what someone says they do and how they approach a scenario. For the behaviour itself you need observation, for example by a manager.
How long should follow-up last? There is no fixed period. For soft skills, six to twelve weeks is common, so there are several moments to try it in real work.
Does this work for short trainings of half a day? Especially there. The shorter the training, the less time there was to practise, and the more the follow-up has to do.
Sources
- Blume, B. D., Ford, J. K., Baldwin, T. T., & Huang, J. L. (2010). Transfer of training: A meta-analytic review. Journal of Management, 36(4), 1065-1105.
- Cepeda, N. J., Pashler, H., Vul, E., Wixted, J. T., & Rohrer, D. (2006). Distributed practice in verbal recall tasks: A review and quantitative synthesis. Psychological Bulletin, 132(3), 354-380.
- Gollwitzer, P. M., & Sheeran, P. (2006). Implementation intentions and goal achievement: A meta-analysis of effects and processes. Advances in Experimental Social Psychology, 38, 69-119.
- Roediger, H. L., & Karpicke, J. D. (2006). Test-enhanced learning: Taking memory tests improves long-term retention. Psychological Science, 17(3), 249-255.
- Systematic review of CPR knowledge, self-efficacy, training history and psychomotor skills (34 studies), James Cook University.